Donating Something Valuable? The Appraisal the IRS Requires (Form 8283, Explained)

If you claim a deduction of more than $5,000 for a donated item, or for a group of similar items, the IRS requires a qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser and Section B of Form 8283, and Form 8283 itself is required once your deduction for noncash gifts passes $500.

A painting for a museum. A diamond necklace for a charity gala. Sterling silver for a local foundation. Gifts like these feel simple on the day you hand them over. The tax paperwork is not simple, and donors often learn the appraisal rule months after the gift, after the valid window has closed. This guide covers the dollar lines, the form, the appraisal, the timing, and the papers to gather first.

This post gives general information, not tax advice. Talk with your tax professional about your return, and talk with a qualified appraiser about the value of the property.

The dollar lines that decide your paperwork

The first line is $500. The IRS states that individuals, partnerships, and corporations file Form 8283 to report noncash charitable contributions when the deduction for all noncash gifts is more than $500. Keep receipts below that line too. A gift of $250 or more needs a written acknowledgment from the charity.

The second line is $5,000, and it triggers the appraisal. A single item past that line needs a qualified appraisal, and a group of similar items counts the same way. Similar items are items of the same general category or type, such as paintings, jewelry, books, or coins, and group items count together even across charities. In most cases you keep the full appraisal in your records. For art at $20,000 or more, attach a complete copy of the signed appraisal to your return. For a claim past $500,000, attach the qualified appraisal as well, subject to limited exceptions in the instructions.

Fair market value is the number the IRS wants

Donation appraisals use fair market value: the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, with both sides holding reasonable knowledge of the facts and no pressure on any side to act. It is not retail replacement cost. A ring that costs $12,000 to replace new may sell for far less on the open market, and the open market figure is the one that belongs on a donation return.

Our guide to insurance value and fair market value walks through the two numbers side by side. Read it before you reuse an old insurance appraisal for a gift, since an insurance report states replacement cost, not fair market value. The appraiser finds fair market value where the item normally sells: auction and dealer sales for art and antiques, and sales of comparable stones and signed pieces for jewelry. Condition, maker, age, and history move the result, and the report has to show that work.

Section A, Section B, and what each part does

Section A covers an item, or a group of similar items, with a claimed deduction of more than $500 and not more than $5,000. Publicly traded securities also go in Section A. Section B covers property past $5,000 per item or group. The instructions are blunt on one point. Form 8283 is an appraisal summary. It is not an appraisal. A separate qualified appraisal stands behind every Section B filing.

Section B has five parts. Part I describes the property, its condition, how and when you got it, your cost or other basis, and the appraised fair market value. Part II covers partial interests and restricted use property, in those cases only. Part III is a donor statement for small items inside a larger group, in narrow cases in the instructions. Part IV is the appraiser declaration, signed by the appraiser. Part V is the donee acknowledgment, signed by the charity to confirm receipt. Complete Part I with the appraisal in hand, then the appraiser signs Part IV, then the charity signs Part V. A missing signature can put the whole deduction at risk.

What a qualified appraisal must contain

A qualified appraisal is a written report prepared under the substance and principles of USPAP, the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, and it must meet the appraisal rules in the tax regulations. The report describes the property in enough detail that a stranger can tell the appraised item is the donated item. It states physical condition, the contribution date, and the valuation effective date. It sets out the method used and the market data behind the conclusion. It states the appraised fair market value, names the appraiser, lists qualifications, and carries the appraiser signature and signing date.

Strong reports include clear photos of each item, plus close views of marks, signatures, and damage. For jewelry, the report describes metal, stones, measurements, grading, and treatment notes. See what a USPAP jewelry appraisal includes for the full list. One fee rule protects you. The appraiser fee cannot rest on a percentage of the appraised value, since a fee tied to value rewards a higher number. Heritage Appraisals charges for time and scope. Current figures sit on the appraisal rates page.

Who counts as a qualified appraiser

A qualified appraiser holds a recognized appraisal designation from a professional appraiser group for the type of property in the report, or meets set education and experience rules for that property type. The appraiser must prepare appraisals on a regular basis for pay. The report must state the background, experience, education, and membership facts that support that status.

Independence is part of the test. The donor cannot act as the appraiser, and the charity that receives the gift cannot act as the appraiser. Close family members, business partners, and other related parties in the instructions are barred as well. A dealer who wants to buy the item has a stake in a low number, and a seller who sold you the item has a stake in a high one. Heritage Appraisals is led by Kelly Knoll, ISA CAPP, the Certified Appraiser of Personal Property designation from the International Society of Appraisers. Its reports follow USPAP for jewelry, art, antiques, and estate property. For estate pieces that overlap with a gift, our estate jewelry appraisal guide shows how date of death values and donation values differ.

Timing rules that catch donors off guard

The appraisal must be signed and dated no earlier than 60 days before the date you contribute the property. An appraisal signed four months before the gift sits outside the window. You must receive the appraisal before the due date, including extensions, of the return where you first claim the deduction.

The safe order follows from those rules. Call the appraiser before you deliver the property, and book the inspection while the item is still in your hands, so the appraiser can see, measure, and photograph it in person. Donors who reverse that order, gift first and call in filing season, force the appraiser to work from photos after the item has left the house. Some items cannot be appraised well that way, and some cannot be appraised at all. For art at $20,000 or more, keep the complete signed appraisal ready to attach, and keep a good photograph ready in case the IRS asks for one. Our notes on art appraisal for probate cover court use of art values, and the same habits help here.

How to prepare your items and papers

Start with a simple list: each item, where it came from, when you got it, what you paid if you know, plus the charity name and planned gift date. That list becomes source material for Part I. Gather papers next: receipts, prior appraisals, lab reports, gallery invoices, auction records, repair bills, and family notes. Provenance, the documented history of ownership, can raise or lower value, and gaps need honest notes, not guesswork. For furniture, our antique and furniture appraisal overview lists the details that matter most.

Handle items with care. Do not polish silver hard before the visit. Do not clean coins. Do not repair a chipped frame or a loose stone first. Condition goes into the report as found, and hard cleaning can cut value and blur marks. Keep loose stones and detached parts in a labeled bag with the item.

A practical example: a painting, a museum, and a deadline

Picture a common case. A Troy homeowner owns a signed oil painting bought years ago, with the gallery invoice still in a file. She plans to give it to a Michigan museum in late November, with a claim well past $5,000. She calls in early October. Good timing.

The inspection takes place at her home, with her present. The appraiser records size, medium, signature, condition, and frame, and photographs the front, back, and signature. Auction sales for the artist support a fair market value as of the planned gift date. She approves the itemized proposal and holds the signed report inside the 60 day window. She completes Part I from the report, the appraiser signs Part IV, and the museum signs Part V when it takes the painting. Her claim passes $20,000, so a complete copy of the signed appraisal goes with the return.

Fees and how booking works

Heritage Appraisals publishes its rates, so you can plan before you call. The standard rate is $150 per hour, covering inspection, research, market analysis, and report writing. You receive an itemized fee breakdown in a formal proposal for approval before work begins, or right after the inspection on larger jobs. The first step is a free 15 minute telephone consultation at (248) 722-4319. Online preliminary reviews start at $20 for the first item and $10 for each added item. Follow up calls and mail beyond the free call run $50 per 30 minutes, and Zoom meetings run $75.

You never need to leave jewelry or valuables behind. The examination takes place with you present, in the Troy office or in your home, and your items stay in your sight. Share your gift date on the first call, since donation work has hard tax windows.

Does a store receipt or a dealer letter count as a qualified appraisal?

No. A receipt proves a purchase price on a past date, and a dealer letter is often a sales paper or a buy offer. A qualified appraisal is a signed written report by a qualified appraiser, prepared under USPAP principles, with a full description, condition notes, method, market support, and fair market value.

Can I use my insurance appraisal for my donation deduction?

No. An insurance appraisal states retail replacement value for coverage, not fair market value. The IRS requires fair market value for a donation deduction. The two reports answer two different questions, and the value type must match the use.

What happens if I already gave the item away last year?

Act fast and get advice. The appraisal must be signed no earlier than 60 days before the gift, and you must receive it before the due date, including extensions, of the return where you first claim the deduction. An appraiser who never saw the item may have too little to work from.

Do I need an appraisal for a group of smaller gifts?

You need Form 8283 once your deduction for noncash gifts passes $500, and a qualified appraisal with Section B once a single item, or a group of similar items, passes $5,000. Similar items count together even across charities, so a set of smaller gifts can cross the line as a group.

Book your donation appraisal before you hand the item over

The safest gift is a planned gift. Before you deliver art, jewelry, silver, or antiques to a charity, submit your items for a donation appraisal or call (248) 722-4319 for a free 15 minute consultation. Share the gift date, the charity name, and the papers you hold.